Saving for retirement is crucial, but it can be challenging to find the most effective way to build your nest egg. Some financial advisors tout certain life insurance policies as potential retirement savings vehicles. But is life insurance a practical strategy for funding your golden years? Here’s an in-depth look at using life insurance as a retirement plan tool.
How Life Insurance Policies Build Cash Value
There are two basic types of life insurance—term and permanent (which includes whole life, universal life, and variable life policies). Term life provides pure death benefit protection for a set period of time. Permanent life insurance has both a death benefit and an accumulating cash value component funded by policy premiums and investment returns. It’s this cash value that allows permanent life insurance to work as a long-term savings vehicle.
Whole life insurance policies build cash value at a fixed rate of return, while universal and variable policies invest the cash value in securities, leading to potentially higher growth but also exposing you to market risk. The cash value portion functions similarly to a tax-deferred savings or investment account.
Using Cash Value for Retirement Income
The main way permanent life insurance could supplement your retirement income is through policy loans and withdrawals. You can typically access a portion of your policy’s cash value tax-free through policy loans that use the death benefit as collateral. The loans reduce the death benefit until repaid.
Many permanent life insurance policies also let you withdraw cash directly. However, withdrawals that exceed what you’ve paid in premiums get taxed as ordinary income. Another option is using your policy’s cash value to fund fixed income annuity payments during retirement.
Pros and Cons of Using Life Insurance for Retirement Savings
Permanent life insurance offers some key benefits as a retirement planning tool:
- Tax-deferred cash value growth
- Ability to access cash value without penalty
- Tax-free policy loans
- Downside protection from market losses
- Allows you to leave a death benefit to beneficiaries
However, there are also some significant drawbacks to consider:
- High premium costs reduce investable funds
- Policy expenses impact net returns
- Minimal or no liquidity during early years
- Misses potential for higher investment returns
- Risk of lapsing if premiums stop and drain cash reserves
A Sensible Approach: Balance and Diversification
Permanent life insurance probably shouldn’t be your only retirement savings vehicle or primary income source later in life due to its costs and limited investment performance compared to vehicles like 401(k)s. However, as part of an overall balanced strategy, a permanent life policy’s tax advantages, lifetime income options and death benefit can complement other retirement accounts and income streams.
A reasonable approach is dedicating your primary retirement assets to stocks, bonds, mutual funds and 401(k)s for growth potential, while using permanent life insurance in moderation for stability, downside protection, tax diversification and beneficiary planning. As with any major financial move, have in-depth discussions with qualified financial and insurance professionals to determine if and where cash value life insurance fits into your specific retirement plan.
The key is balancing tradeoffs and diversifying income sources. Used judiciously alongside your other retirement savings, permanent life insurance can be one piece of the puzzle. But relying on it too heavily could leave you short on income or overly exposed to underperformance. Discuss options with professionals to strike the right equilibrium for your needs.
Interesting Related Article: “The Benefits of Investing in Precious Metals for Retirement“