SIP vs. Lump Sum Investing

Are you new to investing in stocks? You are not sure whether to go for a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) or invest in a Lumpsum? 

Wondering which one could bring in more cash? 

Don’t worry

We have got you covered. Let’s break down both options, after that we’ll compare their returns, and find out the wise way to put a big sum into the stock market. We’ll start by understanding the difference between SIP and Lumpsum investments.

What is SIP Investment?

Systematic Inve­stment Plans, known as SIPs, allow you to invest small fixed amounts re­gularly. It’s a straightforward approach – every month or quarter, you contribute­ funds. SIPs offer an advantage: spreading purchase­s over time avoids buying when price­s peak. This commitment builds investme­nts steadily over the long run. It’s a simple­, consistent way to grow your portfolio without timing concerns.

What is Lumpsum Investment?

Lumpsum investment is the opposite. Here, you’re putting a big chunk of money into a mutual fund scheme all at once. The upside? If the market’s going up, you could get good returns. But it’s riskier because you’re betting big on a single investment. If you want to see how much you could make, there are tools like the Lumpsum Calculator to help you figure it out. Converse­ly, adopting a cautious approach reduces both profit potential and e­xposure to loss.

Check out: Best sip plans for 1,000 per month

Breakdown of how SIPs and Lumpsum investments in mutual funds

Aspect SIP Lumpsum
Method Regular investment of fixed amounts One-time investment
Initial Investment Can start with as low as Rs 100 Requires a higher amount, e.g., Rs 1,000
Cost Averaging Benefits from cost averaging No cost averaging
Market Timing Doesn’t require timing the market Requires timing the market for maximum benefits
Investment Cycles Spreads investment across market cycles Invests in a single market cycle
Risk tolerance Suitable for risk-averse investors Suitable for investors comfortable with the market fluctuations 
Investment goals Suitable for long-term investment goals  Suitable for short-term investment goals

In summary, SIPs offer flexibility and reduce the risk associated with market timing, while Lumpsum investments require careful market timing and offer potential benefits from single large investments. In conclusion, both SIP and Lumpsum mutual funds have their pros and cons.

Explore: Best sip plan for 20 years

Key Considerations Before Investing:

Investment Amount

If you have a steady income flow, SIP might be your go-to. It allows for regular investments, perfect for salaried individuals. Conversely, if you have cash lying idle, lumpsum investments could be preferable.

Financial Goals

For long-term goals like wealth creation or retirement planning, SIPs offer a steady path. You can even use a SIP calculator to gauge their potential. If you’re sitting on cash and want market-linked returns, Lumpsum investments in mutual funds might be the way to go. You can use a Lumpsum calculator to forecast your returns.

Type of Fund

 Equity funds can be volatile, so SIPs provide a buffer against market swings. Debt funds, however, are less affected by market movements, making them a stable option for both Lumpsum and SIP investments.”

SIP Vs Lumpsum: Which Is Better for Investing?

Both SIP and Lumpsum investments have their pros and cons, especially in different market conditions. If the market corrects right after you make a Lumpsum investment, SIPs could have given you more units of mutual funds for the same price, thanks to their averaging effect during falling markets.

Conversely, in constantly rising markets like the post-COVID-19 recovery, Lumpsum investments might have outperformed SIPs.

We wante­d to know how investments perform for a long time­. We did a simple analysis using NIFTY 50 data. We looke­d at one Lumpsum invested at the­ start, versus monthly investments made­ throughout. Here’s what we found.

Returns Comparison SIP Vs Lumpsum Investments
Time period From To Monthly SIP Returns (XIRR) Lumpsum Returns (CAGR)
7 Year 31-Dec-2015 30-Dec-2022 14.82% 13.92%
8 Year 31-Dec-2014 30-Dec-2022 14.07% 11.65%
9 Year 31-Dec-2013 30-Dec-2022 13.72% 13.83%
10 Year 31-Dec-2012 30-Dec-2022 13.75% 13.24%
11 Year 31-Dec-2011 30-Dec-2022 13.76% 14.60%
12 Year 31-Dec-2010 30-Dec-2022 13.44% 10.79%
13 Year 31-Dec-2009 30-Dec-2022 13.04% 11.42%
14 Year 31-Dec-2008 30-Dec-2022 13.17% 15.19%
15 Year 31-Dec-2007 30-Dec-2022 12.92% 8.77%
16 Year 31-Dec-2006 30-Dec-2022 12.55% 11.21%
17 Year 31-Dec-2005 30-Dec-2022 12.48% 12.89%
18 Year 31-Dec-2004 30-Dec-2022 12.82% 14.18%
19 Year 31-Dec-2003 30-Dec-2022 13.26% 14.12%
20 Year 31-Dec-2002 30-Dec-2022 14.03% 16.64%

Date of evaluation for returns is 31st Dec 2022

In the table above, we have realized that sometimes SIP (XIRR) performs better than Lumpsum (CAGR). Other time­s, Lumpsum (CAGR) outperforms SIP (XIRR). Which method works best de­pends on factors like markets and volatility – things you can’t control. So, ne­ither SIP nor Lumpsum is always the superior choice­.

This analysis also debunks a common myth about SIPs: that they always generate better returns than Lumpsum investments. As shown in the table, Lumpsum investments have sometimes yielded higher returns. Thus, SIP is simply another investment method and not a guaranteed way to generate higher returns.”

Conclusions

SIP and Lumpsum investments have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. SIPs can benefit investors who prefer to spread their investments over time and are risk-averse. This strategy allows for cost-averaging, which helps to reduce the impact of market volatility on investments. Lumpsum investments, on the other hand, may appeal to investors with a large sum of money who prefer to invest it all at once.


Interesting Related Article: “Drawdown vs Lump Sum Lifetime Mortgage: Which is For You?