The Ultimate Pre-Employment Screening Checklist

Hiring new employees is an investment in your company’s future, and ensuring that you bring on board individuals with integrity, honesty and the right qualifications is paramount. One of the most crucial steps in the hiring process is conducting comprehensive background checks. 

This checklist will guide you through the key elements of an effective background checks process, helping you make informed hiring decisions and fostering a secure work environment.

Obtain Candidate Consent

Before initiating any background checks, it’s important to obtain written consent from the candidate. This step ensures compliance with legal regulations and demonstrates respect for candidates’ privacy.

The Right To Work

Checking that candidates can legally work is a crucial part of this process. If this is not done, there’s the possibility that the business may have to pay fines.

Criminal History Check

A criminal history check is essential to identify any potential risks associated with a candidate. This check should include a report detailing any convictions that the potential employee may have. 

In the UK, this check is called a DBS check. There are different levels of this check, with an enhanced DBS check providing a huge amount of information compared to a basic DBS check that has a lot less. 

Employment Verification

Verify the accuracy of the candidate’s employment history, including job titles, responsibilities, and dates of employment. This step helps ensure that the candidate’s stated experience aligns with reality.

Education Verification

Confirm the candidate’s educational background by reaching out to the institutions listed on their CV. Verify degrees earned, graduation dates and any certifications claimed. This prevents misrepresentation and ensures that the candidate meets the educational requirements for the role.

Professional License and Certification Check

For positions that require specific licenses or certifications, such as medical professionals or accountants, ensure that the candidate possesses the necessary credentials. Verify the authenticity and current status of these licenses.

Reference Checks

Contact references provided by the candidate to gain insights into their work ethic, interpersonal skills and overall performance. This step provides a valuable perspective from those who have worked closely with the candidate in the past.

Credit History Check (If Relevant)

Depending on the nature of the role, a credit history check may be appropriate. This is particularly relevant for positions that involve financial responsibilities. However, be sure to comply with legal requirements when conducting credit checks.

Social Media Screening

A review of a candidate’s public social media profiles can provide additional insights into their character and behaviour. However, exercise caution to avoid discrimination and respect the candidate’s privacy.

Drug Testing (If Applicable)

In industries where safety is a critical concern, such as transportation or healthcare, drug testing might be necessary. Clearly communicate your company’s drug testing policy to candidates and ensure that the testing is conducted in a fair and consistent manner.

International Background Checks (If Applicable)

If the candidate has lived, worked or studied abroad, consider conducting international background checks to ensure a comprehensive assessment of their history.

Standard Compliance 

Some positions require candidates to meet a standard. For example, individuals that have access to government assets in the United Kingdom must pass a BPSS check

Confidentiality and Data Security

Protect the sensitive information obtained during the background checks process. Implement secure data storage practices and ensure that only authorized personnel have access to the information.

Review and Decision-Making

After gathering all the necessary information, carefully review the results of the background checks. Assess the potential impact of any red flags on the candidate’s ability to perform the job effectively and responsibly.

Communication with the Candidate

If any discrepancies or concerns arise from the background checks, give the candidate an opportunity to explain the situation. Maintain open communication and allow them to provide context.


By following this comprehensive background check checklist, you’ll be better equipped to make informed hiring decisions that contribute to a trustworthy and productive workforce. 

A thorough background check process not only safeguards your company but also helps build a team of individuals who align with your values and mission!

You may be interested in: How to Conduct a Social Media Background Check