REITs vs Mutual Funds: What’s the Difference

When it comes to investing, there are various options available to suit different financial goals and risk appetites. In India’s diverse landscape of investment options, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Mutual Funds are two prominent investment vehicles that cater to a broad range of investors looking for growth, income and diversification. 

According to the Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI), as of July 2024, the Indian mutual fund industry has surpassed a staggering INR 64.97 trillion in assets under management. Simultaneously, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) , although a relatively new entrant in the Indian market as of July 2024 REITS, have approximately over 1.4 trillion assets under management. 

Understanding REITs

Real Estate Investment Trusts, or REITs, own, operate, or finance income-producing real estate. They are modelled after mutual funds and provide individuals with the opportunity to own valuable real estate while also presenting the ability to access dividend-based income and total returns and help diversify an investment portfolio.

In India, REITs are relatively new, with the first REIT being listed in 2019. However, they have opened doors for investors with even a modest amount of capital to enter the real estate market. In this burgeoning sector, investors have the opportunity to reap benefits similar to those of stocks, including regular income through dividends and potential capital appreciation.

How REITs Operate in India

REITs in India are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). They must be listed on exchanges and must distribute at least 90% of their net distributable cash flow to investors at least twice a year. The primary structures include:

1. Retail REITs: These REITs invest in shopping malls, restaurants, and retail stores.
2. Office REITs: Focus on office buildings and may spread across major cities.
3. Residential REITs: Include investments in rented residential buildings.
4. Mixed-use REITs: Combine any of the above types into a single portfolio.

Performance of REITs in India

The market has shown promising development since the introduction of REITs in India. For instance, Embassy Office Parks REIT, Brookfield India REIT, and Mindspace REIT have all seen consistent performance since their inception. Each one of these REITs has delivered an impressive return, evidencing the potential growth of this sector and their resilience in the fluctuating real estate market.  

Understanding Mutual Funds

Mutual Funds have been a familiar term in the Indian investor’s lexicon for quite some time. A mutual fund pools money from numerous investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, or other securities, depending on the fund’s investment objectives. Mutual Funds are managed by professional fund managers who allocate the fund’s investments with the aim of producing capital gains or income for the fund’s investors. The portfolio’s performance is tracked as the change in the total market capitalization of the fund’s holdings.

Types of Mutual Funds in India (based on asset class)

Mutual Funds in India come in various forms to suit different investment preferences and risk tolerances:

1. Equity Funds (or Stock Funds) – These funds invest primarily in stocks and are known for their high potential for growth.
2. Debt Funds – Focused on investments in bonds and other debt instruments, these funds are preferred by individuals looking for steady income with lower risk.
3. Money Market Funds – Invested in short-term fixed-income securities, these are considered safe and highly liquid.
4. Hybrid Funds – Combining stocks and bonds, these funds balance the risk and returns by diversifying the investments.
5. Index Funds and ETFs – These funds mimic the performance of a specific index, like the NIFTY or the SENSEX.

Besides these classifications based on asset class, mutual funds can also be categorized by their investment goals and the level of risk involved. Investors can choose from growth funds, tax-saving funds, very low- to high-risk options, and even real estate mutual funds or emerging market funds, depending on their risk appetite, investment horizon, and financial objectives. This versatility makes mutual funds a flexible choice for novice and experienced investors.

Performance of Mutual Funds in India

The performance of Mutual Funds in India can vary widely depending on the fund’s investment focus. The market has witnessed a significant uptrend in certain sectors, leading to higher returns for specific equity funds. 

Mutual Funds in India also offer tax-saving options under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act via Equity Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS), which have a lock-in period of three years and can yield benefits both in terms of returns and tax deductions. With Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), investors can contribute small amounts regularly, making Mutual Funds an accessible investment option for all types of investors, irrespective of their investment capital.

This makes Mutual Funds, including those focused on various risk profiles like very low-risk funds, high-risk funds, and real estate mutual funds an accessible investment option for all types of investors, irrespective of their investment capital through Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs).

With Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), investors can contribute small amounts regularly, making Mutual Funds an accessible investment option for all types of investors, irrespective of their investment capital.

With professional management, diversification, and liquidity, Mutual Funds have been a stepping stone for Indian investors looking to get into the capital markets.

Comparative Analysis of REITs vs Mutual Funds

There are several key factors that need to be evaluated to determine whether REITs or Mutual Funds align better with your individual financial goals, risk tolerance and investment strategy. Here’s a comparative analysis on mutual funds vs REITs based on essential investment metrics:

Investment Objectives

• REITs

They are primarily focused on generating income through rental yields and capital appreciation on real estate. They’re suitable for those interested in real estate investment without the direct ownership responsibilities.

• Mutual Funds

They offer a border range of objectives depending on the type of fund—growth, income, or preservation of capital in various asset classes (equities, debt, etc.). They are suitable for a range of financial goals, from saving for retirement to building corpus in the short term.

Liquidity 

• REITs

They are fairly liquid, as they are traded on major stock exchanges. 

• Mutual Funds

They are highly liquid, especially open-ended funds, which allow investors to buy and sell units at the fund’s current net asset value (NAV) each trading day.

Risk Profile

• REITs

They have risks associated with real estate market conditions, interest rate sensitivity, and tenant vacancies. However, they generally offer stable incomes and can be vulnerable to market downturns that affect property values.

• Mutual Funds

Their risk varies significantly across different types of funds. Equity funds may offer high risk-high return opportunities, while debt funds typically provide lower risk and stable returns.

Returns

• REITs

With REITs, there is potential for stable income through dividends plus capital appreciation. The total returns depend heavily on the property market and the management of the REIT.

• Mutual Funds

Returns can vary widely with mutual funds. Equity funds aim for high capital growth, whereas debt funds focus on income stability.

Tax Implications

• REITs

Dividends received from REITs are taxable. Capital gains from the sale of REIT units are subject to short-term or long-term capital gains tax, depending on the holding period.

• Mutual Funds

Tax treatment varies with the type of fund. Long-term capital gains on equity funds are taxed at 10% for gains exceeding INR 1 lakh without indexation, while debt funds are taxed at 20% with indexation after three years. Dividends are taxable to investors at their respective slab rates.

Costs

• REITs

Typically incurs lower transaction costs compared to direct real estate investments, but investors might need to look out for management fees and transaction charges.

• Mutual Funds

Management fees, entry loads (in some cases), and exit loads can impact the overall return. However, direct plans of mutual funds have lower expense ratios compared to regular plans.

Which Should You Choose?

The decision between REITs vs Mutual Funds depends on your individual investment goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon.

Choose REITs if:

• You’re looking for a steady income stream.
• You want exposure to real estate without directly buying property.
• You’re comfortable with the risks associated with real estate markets.

Choose Mutual Funds if:

• You want broad diversification across various asset classes.
• You prefer professional management of your investments.
• You’re seeking a mix of income and growth potential.

Both REITs and Mutual Funds can play a valuable role in a diversified investment portfolio. By understanding their differences, you can better align your investment choices with your financial goals.

References 

https://indianreitsassociation.com/

https://cleartax.in/s/different-mutual-funds-taxed

https://www.icicibank.com/blogs/mutual-fund/types-of-mutual-funds-in-india

https://www.amfiindia.com/indian-mutual

---

Interesting Related Article: “How to Successfully Navigate the Real Estate Market“