An overhead view of stocked supermarket shelves appears in a representative photograph by freestocks.org/Pexels.

A loyalty campaign can lose sales when stores struggle to carry it out

Written by Joseph Nordqvist

Published: 20:00, November 10, 2026

Missing signs, incomplete displays and unavailable rewards can undermine a retail loyalty campaign, according to research that tracked how a temporary program was carried out in stores.

The study, published in the Journal of Retailing, linked differences in store-level execution with sales patterns and reward redemption. Its findings highlight a practical question for marketers: can employees and customers use the promotion as it was designed?

The evidence comes from one temporary loyalty program. The observed relationships should not be treated as a guaranteed estimate of losses at every retailer or proof that a single missing sign caused a particular decline.

What happens between planning and the shop floor

Temporary loyalty programs give shoppers a limited period to collect points or stamps and claim a reward. Their success depends on customers noticing the offer, understanding the requirements and being able to obtain the reward.

Suzanne Bies, Nick Bombaij, Bart Bronnenberg and Els Gijsbrechts combined information about in-store execution with sales data from before, during and after a program. The researchers examined signs, displays, staff support and reward availability.

They reported widespread gaps in execution and documented patterns of sales losses and changes in reward redemption associated with those gaps. Operational conditions and demand intensity were also linked to the level of store engagement.

A campaign can therefore look consistent in a central marketing plan while appearing quite different to customers across locations. A shopper cannot respond to a display that was never installed, and a customer who has earned a reward may be frustrated if it is unavailable.

Availability is part of the promise

Reward availability matters because loyalty programs ask customers to act over time. Someone may make repeated purchases in order to reach a threshold. If the reward is difficult to claim, the problem can affect both the immediate transaction and confidence in future offers.

Retailers can compare projected demand with stock and delivery capacity before launch. During the campaign, store teams need a practical way to report shortages and explain what customers can do if a reward is unavailable. These are operational suggestions, not interventions tested separately in the study.

The design of the reward itself also matters. MBN’s guide to customer loyalty explains the wider relationship between repeat purchases and customer experience.

Measure delivery as well as results

A retailer assessing a promotion might track whether signs are in place, staff understand the rules, displays are accessible and rewards remain in stock. Those checks can sit alongside sales, participation and redemption figures.

Comparisons between stores need care. Busy locations, staffing differences and local demand may affect both execution and sales. A weak result should not automatically be blamed on a particular employee or display.

A controlled trial, where practical, can help separate the effect of a campaign change from other differences. Managers should also consider the cost of improving execution and whether the same resources could produce better results elsewhere.

The study’s value is in showing that a promotion is not finished when its terms are approved. Its outcome also depends on the materials, inventory and support customers encounter when they visit a store.

Joseph Nordqvist Avatar

Other News

Small changes in a store can bring promotions back to repeat customers’ attention

Nov 18, 2026

Some sellers accept less when a buyer shares an item’s heritage

Nov 18, 2026

Changing a marketplace trust badge can change what sellers prioritize

Nov 18, 2026

Referred customers may bring in more customers of their own

Nov 18, 2026

An extra option can make an attractive menu less appealing, experiments find

Nov 17, 2026

Adding similar choices can change which products look like the middle option

Nov 17, 2026

World Bank plans e-commerce pilot for small firms in three West African countries

Nov 17, 2026

Contextual ads were the most common targeting method among EU online advertisers

Nov 17, 2026

People treat the same money differently across spending categories, study finds

Nov 17, 2026

Small-business loan applications can stall before they are formally submitted

Nov 17, 2026

Describing the parts of an experience can change how much people enjoy it

Nov 16, 2026

A prize can feel different when customers know they might have received less

Nov 16, 2026

Frequent rating requests can change how customers experience a service

Nov 16, 2026

How a business handles customer data can shape its relationship with buyers

Nov 16, 2026

Trying a customized product can shape what shoppers choose later

Nov 16, 2026

Why the way unit prices are shown can change how shoppers judge a deal

Nov 16, 2026

Why the weather can affect ratings of cold-weather gear

Nov 15, 2026

Seeing a purchase as part of a collection can change the shopping experience

Nov 15, 2026

Retail app ads may influence what customers do after installation

Nov 15, 2026

A bank tested AI customer twins for marketing, with mixed lessons for businesses

Nov 15, 2026