Total return measures an investment’s change in value together with the income it produces over a stated period. It includes capital losses as well as gains, so a positive dividend does not guarantee a positive return.
FINRA distinguishes the money gained or lost from the percentage rate of return. Price return captures only the change in price. Total return also includes income such as dividends or interest, with the calculation’s assumptions clearly stated.

A simple formula with cash income
For a holding with an unchanged share count and income taken as cash, before fees and taxes:
Total return (%) = (ending value − starting value + cash income) ÷ starting value × 100.
Suppose 100 shares cost $40 each, making a $4,000 initial investment. They finish at $44 each, worth $4,400, and pay $200 in cash dividends. The gain is $400 plus $200, or $600. Dividing $600 by $4,000 gives a 15% total return.
If the ending price were $36 instead, the $400 price loss less the $200 income would leave a $200 loss, or −5%.
What changes when dividends are reinvested?
Reinvestment buys more shares, so the eventual result depends on the purchase price and subsequent price changes. Assume the same $200 dividend buys five additional shares at $40 before the price reaches $44.
The resulting 105 shares are worth $4,620. The $620 increase over the original $4,000 is 15.5%. The reinvested dividend is already represented by those additional shares; adding another $200 would double-count it.

Reinvestment does not always improve the outcome. A subsequent price fall can reduce the value of the newly purchased shares too.
Cumulative and annualised returns
A cumulative return covers the entire stated period. An annualised return expresses a multi-year result as an equivalent compounded yearly rate. For example, 21% over two years corresponds to 10% a year because 1.10 × 1.10 = 1.21, not 10.5% a year.
Morningstar’s calculation notes distinguish cumulative and annualised figures. Returns for a short period are not automatically annualised, and different reporting conventions can produce different presentations.
How reported figures differ
S&P Dow Jones Indices explains that a total-return equity index assumes dividend reinvestment. Its net total-return calculations also apply specified dividend withholding-tax assumptions. An index calculation need not equal an individual investor’s after-tax result.
The SEC explains how investment fees reduce returns. Contributions and withdrawals also require an appropriate performance method. A bigger account balance alone does not reveal how well the investments performed.
Last checked and updated on November 3, 2026 by the MBN editorial team.