Super Micro Computer’s decline – accounting scandals, stock collapse, and future uncertainties

Super Micro Computer Inc. (NASDAQ: SMCI) was once the darling of the AI hardware sector, celebrated for its amazing growth.

Unfortunately, a series of recent accounting controversies, scandals, and executive changes have triggered a drastic fall in its stock price. Today, stakeholders, investors, and market experts have doubts about the company’s future.

Let’s explore the key issues impacting Super Micro’s valuation, investor confidence, and the implications for its potential delisting from Nasdaq.

---

Accounting Issues and Auditor Resignations

Super Micro Computer has faced scrutiny over its financial reporting practices. In August 2024, short-seller Hindenburg Research accused the company of accounting manipulation, which drew significant attention to its practices.

These allegations, plus a subsequent delay in Super Micro’s financial filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), raised red flags for investors and the media.

It was not long before Nasdaq informed the company that it was not complying with listing rules.

---

Auditor said it could not trust Super Micro

Most recently, Ernst & Young (EY), the company’s auditing firm, resigned. This was the second time in less than two years that Super Micro lost an auditor.

EY cited concerns over management’s representations and stated that it was no longer willing to be associated with the financial statements prepared by management. Put simply, EY said that it could not trust them.

According to Yahoo Finance, in a resignation letter, EY said:

“We are resigning due to information that has recently come to our attention which has led us to no longer be able to rely on management’s and the Audit Committee’s representations and to be unwilling to be associated with the financial statements prepared by management, and after concluding we can no longer provide the Audit Services in accordance with applicable law or professional obligations.”

EY’s abrupt resignation has fueled further concerns about the accuracy and reliability of Super Micro’s reported financials and its internal accounting controls.

---

Government Investigations and Potential Legal Consequences

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has also initiated an investigation into Super Micro. The company faces accusations of engaging in questionable business deals with companies owned by the CEO’s family members, as well as potential dealings with Russian entities that may have violated sanctions.

Details of the DOJ investigation remain limited. However, the probe adds another layer of uncertainty to Super Micro’s future.

Legal and regulatory pressures could make it harder for the company to operate freely. If sanctions violations or accounting irregularities are confirmed, Super Micro may face even greater challenges in operating effectively in today’s fiercely competitive marketplace.

---

Impact on Stock and Market Value

In a single week, Super Micro’s share price has dropped approximately 45%. All of this year’s stock price gains have been wiped out, and its market cap has been reduced by about $55 billion.

This is a sharp contrast to earlier this year when the company was added to the S&P 500, driven by optimism around its AI server business. The S&P 500 is a key U.S. stock index of 500 large companies. Inclusion is seen as a positive milestone, attracting investor interest and boosting a company’s credibility and stock stability.

Since then, the company’s share price nosedived from a peak of $118.81 to around $26, a drop of more than 78%.

There is widespread concern among stakeholders and the broader market about the company’s future viability.

Many analysts have downgraded Super Micro’s stock, relegating it from a “Buy” to a “Hold” due to the lack of clarity on financial performance and possible future legal ramifications. Analysts may rate shares using the following terms:

• Buy – Analysts expect the stock to rise, making it a good investment opportunity.
• Hold – Current investors should keep the stock, but new investors may want to wait. Market experts expect it to perform on par with the market.
• Sell – The market expects the stock to decline, so investors may consider selling to avoid losses.

While some investors remain optimistic, hoping for a recovery, many are steering clear of the stock given the current risks.

---

Super Micro’s Outlook and Potential for Recovery

Despite the accounting scandals, suspected illegal business practices, and stock price crash, Super Micro’s underlying business remains strong, with ongoing demand for its AI server products.

Key clients like NVIDIA, Microsoft, and IBM continue to use Super Micro’s technology, which may stabilize revenues in the short term.

Its Nasdaq listing will be under threat if it cannot file timely financial reports and find a new auditor. It has until mid-November to comply with Nasdaq’s filing requirements.

Delisting from Nasdaq would further dampen investor confidence and restrict access to capital.

Super Micro Computer’s current situation should remind us of the importance of transparent financial reporting and robust internal controls.

While demand for its AI products may offer a lifeline, one wonders about the company’s long-term success if it cannot restore investor trust.