Books arranged on shelves in a representative bookstore photograph by Viktor Talashuk / Pexels.

Seeing a purchase as part of a collection can change the shopping experience

Written by Joseph Nordqvist

Published: 17:00, November 15, 2026

People prompted to think of purchases as additions to a collection found products more desirable in a series of consumer studies, according to research accepted by the Journal of Marketing.

The work looks at an activity retailers often try to make faster: searching for a product. For some shoppers, looking for a meaningful addition to a collection may be part of the appeal rather than a delay to eliminate.

Elena Bocchi, Adam Greenberg and Zachary Estes report seven preregistered studies and a supplemental study involving 3,306 participants in total. Their accepted manuscript examines product desirability and the experience of searching in several settings.

Some shoppers seek a specific item; others may enjoy exploring possible additions to a collection.

What the researchers tested

In one study, participants imagined owning either one T-shirt or several related shirts before considering another purchase. Other tests asked people to search for items they collected or had several of, using online shopping settings.

The collecting framing generally increased reported product desirability in the tested situations. The researchers also found that participants could enjoy the search more when they thought of it as building a collection.

Most outcomes involved stated willingness or ratings, rather than long-term sales records. A supplemental study used a choice with real incentives, but the results still do not establish the revenue effect of adding a collection feature to an actual store.

When searching may be rewarding

The benefit depended on what people were searching for and whether the process helped them build a collection that mattered to them. If a search yielded an item they already owned or the collection did not fit an identity they valued, the effect could weaken or reverse.

That distinction can help a retailer think about design. Someone seeking a specific replacement part may value a direct route to checkout. A collector browsing books, records or other items may appreciate useful filters, condition details and the ability to compare versions.

These are practical examples, not interventions tested as a package in the paper. The right experience depends on the shopper’s purpose.

Give customers a choice

Retailers can make browsing engaging without making ordinary tasks unnecessarily difficult. Clear search, accurate availability and an easy checkout remain important for people who already know what they want.

A business considering a collection feature could test whether it helps customers find relevant items, then examine purchases, returns and satisfaction as well as time spent browsing. More time on a site might reflect enjoyment, confusion or difficulty finding an item.

Product descriptions should be accurate, especially when discussing rarity or condition. Our reporting on ingredient descriptions shows how product descriptions can shape customer decisions.

The study adds nuance to a familiar design question. Speed matters, but a useful shopping experience can also allow people to explore when exploration is what they came to do.

Joseph Nordqvist Avatar

Other News

Retail app ads may influence what customers do after installation

Nov 15, 2026

A bank tested AI customer twins for marketing, with mixed lessons for businesses

Nov 15, 2026

What makes a product vintage, and why the distinction matters to retailers

Nov 15, 2026

EU business social media use rises, but a gap remains by company size

Nov 15, 2026

Why startups may benefit from testing locally before expanding abroad

Nov 14, 2026

Novel product ideas can be harder to try but more rewarding afterward

Nov 14, 2026

What is in an online cart can influence whether shoppers check out

Nov 14, 2026

Subscription plans can miss customers who would save money, Lyft research finds

Nov 14, 2026

Workers with worse shifts than their colleagues were more likely to leave, restaurant study finds

Nov 14, 2026

More product options do not always reach more customers, cosmetics study finds

Nov 14, 2026

EU household spending grew in 2025 as communication purchases led gains

Nov 13, 2026

Ad experiments can help predict which campaigns drive additional sales

Nov 13, 2026

Browser choice screens lifted Firefox usage in Europe, researchers find

Nov 13, 2026

Online product rankings can cut shipping costs without reducing sales, experiment finds

Nov 13, 2026

Large companies lead EU service exports, but smaller firms dominate in some markets

Nov 13, 2026

Cart reminder timing is linked to different shopper responses

Nov 12, 2026

AI labels changed how consumers judged food images in three experiments

Nov 12, 2026

Shared AI tools were linked to higher sales for small online sellers

Nov 12, 2026

An image ad people like may not be the one they remember

Nov 12, 2026

Upfront rental prices changed competition as nightly rates rose in a study

Nov 12, 2026