A desktop monitor and laptop on an office desk, a representative business software photograph by Mikhail Nilov from Pexels.

Paid AI customers switch providers as new models appear

Written by Joseph Nordqvist

Published: 18:00, October 27, 2026

Consumers paying for generative AI services often switch or cancel subscriptions, according to an October study of US card transactions. The pattern gives rival providers an opening to attract customers, while making recurring revenue less predictable.

Researchers Mark Egan, Dominic Russel, Claire Shi and Vincent Yao examined payments to four major providers: OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and xAI. In April 2026, 2.9% of consumers in their baseline data paid for at least one of the identified services.

The National Bureau of Economic Research working paper estimates annual customer retention between 20% and 45% across the providers. Switching increased around major model releases, and most paying consumers used entry-level plans.

The card records do not capture free users or enterprise accounts. The findings describe the observed US consumer-payment sample through April 2026, not current worldwide usage. The working paper has not been peer reviewed.

What card payments can show

The researchers used anonymized Fiserv credit and debit card data from January 2021 to April 2026. The original dataset covered 174 million consumers and 114 billion transactions. To make it more likely that a person’s primary card was observed, the baseline analysis restricted observations to individual months with at least 20 transactions, reducing the sample to 82 million consumers.

The 2.9% figure should be read against that filtered sample and its method of identifying purchases, not as a count of everyone who has tried an AI chatbot. It excludes people using free tiers and services paid for through enterprise arrangements.

Paid adoption was higher among younger and higher-income consumers in the data. OpenAI accounted for the largest observed share, while the paper also reports rapid growth in Anthropic payments after a model release.

Transactions can show that a charge occurred, but not precisely why a customer chose a tool, whether someone used a free account elsewhere, or how satisfied they were with an answer. The researchers combine the observed patterns with a model to estimate demand and substitution among services.

Retention and switching affect the business case

Retention measures the proportion of a group of paying customers still subscribed after a specified period. A low annual rate can make growth dependent on continually attracting new customers, although customers may return or use other payment channels.

Some consumers paid for more than one AI service, a practice called multihoming. The paper says this became less common as providers’ capabilities expanded. Its model suggests customers became more willing to substitute one service for another.

Those patterns are not proof that all AI products are interchangeable. A customer may need a particular feature, integration, privacy arrangement or model capability that is missing elsewhere. The paper’s conclusions concern the products and consumers it could observe.

Our earlier reporting examined how AI agents are changing business software pricing. Enterprise contracts can combine per-user fees and usage charges; the new research instead focuses on consumer subscriptions paid by card.

Price is only one cost of changing tools

For individual buyers, a lower monthly charge matters alongside the work needed to move saved conversations, files or workflows. Businesses evaluating AI products also have to consider security, administrative controls and the cost of training employees, none of which can be inferred from a consumer’s card payment.

The researchers’ estimated model points to substantial price sensitivity and competitive pressure. Their forecast about future pricing power depends on how products evolve and on the model’s assumptions, rather than guaranteeing future price cuts.

The paper discloses that Yao is a paid Fiserv consultant and both Yao and Egan serve on its advisory council without pay. Yao states that Fiserv did not direct the study’s design, analysis or publication.

For providers, new model launches may bring opportunities to win subscribers from competitors. Whether those customers stay will depend on the usefulness of the product, its price and the alternatives available after the initial launch.

Joseph Nordqvist Avatar

Other News

Product reviews can influence how shoppers assess environmental claims

Nov 3, 2026

Discounts for infrequent buyers can affect how regular customers feel

Nov 3, 2026

Sponsored post frequency has an uneven relationship with influencer engagement

Nov 3, 2026

Regular giving can affect how customers view corporate donations, study finds

Nov 2, 2026

How describing the same food as having few ingredients can change interest

Nov 2, 2026

Suggested prices can change what marketplace sellers earn, Mercari experiment finds

Nov 2, 2026

A change of month can make a sale feel farther away, marketing study suggests

Nov 2, 2026

New and established brands drew different responses to advertising appeals in study

Nov 2, 2026

Community promotions gave lesser-known authors a sales lift in Quebec study

Nov 2, 2026

Believable price guarantees linked to greater trust in retailer survey

Nov 1, 2026

Where customers receive free samples can affect what they do next

Nov 1, 2026

Branded search ads showed no clear sales lift in small business tests

Nov 1, 2026

Tokenized markets promise faster trades, but legal rights and liquidity remain unresolved

Nov 1, 2026

Internet coverage alone cannot close the digital divide, World Bank says

Nov 1, 2026

Energy upgrades can save businesses money, but financing the work remains a hurdle

Nov 1, 2026

Why tighter credit can disrupt supply chains before orders disappear

Oct 31, 2026

South Africa plans a more open payments system as digital transactions grow

Oct 31, 2026

African cities face a jobs test as urban populations grow

Oct 31, 2026

Online platforms can open foreign markets, but sellers still face costs

Oct 31, 2026

Trade barriers beyond tariffs can keep Balkan exporters from growing

Oct 31, 2026